NJIC Football
Division: Liberty
Championship Team: Rutherford
Coach of the Year: Steve Dunn – Rutherford
OFFENSE FIRST TEAM
| POSITION | NAME | GRADE | SCHOOL |
| OL | Troy Waddell | 11 | Rutherford |
| OL | Luke Fairchild | 11 | Waldwick/Midland Park |
| OL | Logan Feehan | 11 | Waldwick/Midland Park |
| OL | Leighton Kelly | 12 | Glen Rock |
| OL | Mickey Oakes | 12 | Glen Rock |
| QB | Myles Balchan | 11 | Rutherford |
| QB | Dylan Ferrara | 12 | Waldwick/Midland Park |
| QB | Brendan Burkhardt | 12 | Glen Rock |
| QB | Jake Lewin | 11 | Creskill/Emerson |
| TE | Quinn Weber | 10 | Rutherford |
| TE | Sebastian Lopez | 12 | Pompton Lakes |
| RB | John Gioia | 10 | Rutherford |
| RB | Tyree Gunthrope | 12 | Manchester |
| RB | Matt Boisits | 12 | Glen Rock |
| WR | Anthony Nunziato | 11 | Rutherford |
| WR | Allam Abdelrehim | 12 | Manchester |
DEFENSE FIRST TEAM
| DL | Evan Diaz | 11 | Rutherford |
| DL | Brian Rock | 12 | Waldwick/Midland Park |
| DL | Jacob Soler | 12 | North Arlington |
| PUNTER | Andy Arrighi | 12 | Glen Rock |
| LB | John Kozlik | 11 | Rutherford |
| LB | Erick Berrouet | 12 | Glen Rock |
| LB | Jack Spitaleri | 10 | Glen Rock |
| LB | Luciano Mayer | 10 | Waldwick/Midland Park |
| LB | Max Reiner | 12 | Cresskill/Emerson |
| LB | Nick Giella | 12 | Creskill/Emerson |
| LB | Redon Xheladini | 12 | Pompton Lakes |
| LB | Christian Murcia | 11 | Pompton Lakes |
| DB | JoJo Marullo | 10 | Rutherford |
| DB | Joey Connelly | 12 | Creskill/Emerson |
OFFENSE SECOND TEAM
| OL | Matt Bonagura | 11 | Rutherford |
| OL | Chase Martini | 10 | Rutherford |
| OL | Justin Aungst | 12 | Pompton Lakes |
| OL | Joey Alloy | 11 | Pompton Lakes |
| OL | Joe Silva | 12 | Glen Rock |
| OL | Matt Buttino | 10 | Waldwick/Midland Park |
| OL | Max Martinez | 12 | Manchester |
| RB | Dmitri Paskas | 11 | Rutherford |
| WR | Tyler Brassil | 12 | Glen Rock |
| WR | Luca Cassano | 11 | Glen Rock |
| WR | Jake Wonsowicz | 11 | Waldwick/Midland Park |
| WR | Justin Soh | 12 | Creskill/Emerson |
| K | Graham Jordan | 11 | Rutherford |
DEFENSE SECOND TEAM
| DL | David Bogosian | 12 | Rutherford |
| DL | Gavin Brown | 10 | Glen Rock |
| DL | Nate Plesnarski | 10 | Glen Rock |
| DL | Josiah Wheeland | 12 | Waldwick/Midland Park |
| DL | Evan Kersul | 12 | Cresskill/Emerson |
| DL | Erion Murseli | 10 | Pompton Lakes |
| LB | Hank Schroeder | 11 | Rutherford |
| LB | Liran Or-Chen | 10 | Glen Rock |
| LB | Alex Ponce-Montes | 10 | Cresskill/Emerson |
| LB | Aden Thomas | 11 | Manchester |
| DB | Leo Kim | 11 | Rutherford |
| DB | Lorenzo Airey | 11 | Rutherford |
| DB | Kenny Gibbs | 10 | Glen Rock |
| DB | Hunter Mansfield | 11 | North Arlington |
| DB | Tyler Lore | 12 | Creskill/Emerson |
| DB | JJ Daniello | 11 | Waldwick/Midland Park |
| DB | Mason Major | 12 | Waldwick/Midland Park |
HONORABLE MENTION
| NAME | GRADE | SCHOOL |
| Russ Snyder | 11 | Rutherford |
| Will Holman | 10 | Rutherford |
| Connor Rice | 12 | Waldwick/Midland Park |
| Matt Elsasser | 12 | Waldwick/Midland Park |
| Anthony Gomez | 11 | Manchester |
| Eduardo De Soto | 11 | Manchester |
| Jonathan Tiberio | 12 | Pompton Lakes |
| Gabriel Arequipa | 10 | Pompton Lakes |
| Julian Castanheira | 11 | North Arlington |
| James Kryatzis | 12 | North Arlington |
| Matt Walsh | 12 | Glen Rock |
| Jackson Fuller | 12 | Glen Rock |
| Mason Mulhern | 10 | Cresskill/Emerson |
| Colin Mattessich | 11 | Cresskill/Emerson |
