NJIC Softball 2026
DIVISION: Colonial
CHAMPIONSHIP TEAM: Waldwick
COACH OF THE YEAR: Mike Kilgallen (Waldwick)
FIRST TEAM
| Position | Name | Grade | School |
| Pitcher | Abby Buser | 10 | Waldwick |
| Catcher | Sophia Clossey | 11 | Rutherford |
| Infielder | Anabella Cole | 11 | Butler |
| Outfielder | Kayla Knapp | 10 | Rutherford |
| First Base | Gianna Marco | 10 | Waldwick |
| At-Large | Emily Ignacio | 11 | Leonia – Bogota |
| At-Large | Mikayla Eutermarks | 11 | Butler |
| At-Large | Lauren Stewart | 11 | Park Ridge |
| At-Large | Ava DeCicco | 11 | Waldwick |
| At-Large | Melany Campos | 11 | Wallington |
| At-Large | Kate Broderick | 12 | Park Ridge |
| At-Large | Stacy Carracozza | 12 | Park Ridge |
| At-Large | Gabby Messina | 10 | Waldwick |
| At-Large | Kyra Rahulatharan | 12 | Waldwick |
| At-Large | Sofia Tran | 9 | Rutherford |
| At-Large | Juliet Gramuglia | 10 | Leonia – Bogota |
| At-Large | Brooke Demmers | 10 | Butler |
SECOND TEAM
| Position | Name | Grade | School |
| At-Large | Ella Caserta | 10 | Waldwick |
| At-Large | Carleigh Nocito | 12 | Waldwick |
| At-Large | Mia Ferguson | 11 | Park Ridge |
| At-Large | Sofia Franolic | 9 | Park Ridge |
| At-Large | Payton Lewis | 11 | Rutherford |
| At-Large | Janina Barna | 12 | Rutherford |
| At-Large | Juliet Sclafane | 9 | Leonia – Bogota |
| At-Large | Jennifer Grebowiec | 12 | Wallington |
| At-Large | Samantha McGinn | 11 | Wallington |
| At-Large | Giada Huber | 10 | Butler |
| At-Large | Kara Morgan | 11 | Butler |
| At-Large | Isabella Marut | 10 | Butler |
HONORABLE MENTION
| Name | Grade | School |
| Kyli Morgan | 11 | Butler |
| Annabel Sohn | 11 | Leonia – Bogota |
| Parker Fajardo | 9 | Rutherford |
| Hailey Koptyra | 9 | Wallington |
| Maggie Seifert | 11 | Waldwick |
| Teni Richard | 10 | Park Ridge |
