NJIC 2023-2024 Girls Basketball
Division: Colonial
Championship Team: Glen Rock
Coach of the Year (and school): Steve Grenz Glen Rock
| First Team | Grade | School |
| Emily McKegney | 11 | Glen Rock |
| Natalie Luftman | 12 | Glen Rock |
| Mia Vergel de Dios | 10 | Glen Rock |
| Maggie Harris | 12 | Glen Rock |
| Kirsten Braunius | 11 | Eastern Christian |
| Mia Soto | 11 | Pompton Lakes |
| Mackenzie Wynbeek | 12 | Eastern Christian |
| Madelyn DiPillo | 10 | Pompton Lakes |
| Second Team | Grade | School |
| Emily Costello | 11 | Butler |
| Abby Grove | 10 | Glen Rock |
| Madison Meyers | 11 | Butler |
| Addison Fleming | 9 | Eastern Christian |
| Caroline Pringle | 10 | Eastern Christian |
| Rayana Brownridge | 10 | Pompton Lakes |
| Emma Struble | 12 | Pompton Lakes |
| Katie Nadirashvili | 11 | Hawthorne |
| Honorable Mention | Grade | School |
| Erza Murseli | 11 | Pompton Lakes |
| Allie Dieckmann | 10 | Butler |
| Isabella Flaccavento | 9 | Glen Rock |
| Aniyah White | 10 | Hawthorne |
| Tori Brown | 10 | Eastern Christian |
