NJIC Softball 2026
DIVISION: American
CHAMPIONSHIP TEAM: New Milford & Cresskill
COACH OF THE YEAR: Alyson Doherty (New Milford)
FIRST TEAM
| Position | Name | Grade | School |
| Pitcher | Sophia Coleman | 12 | Cresskill |
| Catcher | Brianna Maye | 10 | New Milford |
| Infielder | Angelina Cerece | 10 | Cresskill |
| Outfielder | Sabrina Santee | 11 | New Milford |
| First Base | Aliyah Lavandier | 12 | New Milford |
| At-Large | Brianna Depalo | 9 | Cresskill |
| At-Large | Lily Simonetta | 9 | Cresskill |
| At-Large | Brooke Gilchrist | 9 | New Milford |
| At-Large | Jayla Alcivar | 12 | New Milford |
| At-Large | Kendahl Hibinski | 10 | New Milford |
| At-Large | Analeigh Feliciano | 11 | Paterson Charter |
| At-Large | Lexi-Marie Feliciano | 11 | Paterson Charter |
| At-Large | Ava Illuzzi | 10 | Secaucus |
| At-Large | Maryjury Lorenzo | 10 | Manchester |
| At-Large | Kasandra Rodriguez | 11 | Harrison |
| At-Large | Belen Acevedo | 12 | Garfield |
SECOND TEAM
| Position | Name | Grade | School |
| At-Large | Casey DiGirolamo | 11 | New Milford |
| At-Large | Angelina Engelhardt | 10 | New Milford |
| At-Large | Kaelynn Rodriguez | 9 | Manchester |
| At-Large | Annabella Doto | 9 | Cresskill |
| At-Large | Katie Kim | 9 | Cresskill |
| At-Large | Lilah Jamieson | 9 | Cresskill |
| At-Large | Dez-Miyah White | 9 | Paterson Charter |
| At-Large | Saige Coates | 10 | Paterson Charter |
| At-Large | Jenna Raccuia | 11 | Secaucus |
| At-Large | Kaylie Bartletta | 12 | Secaucus |
| At-Large | Lianna Mendoza | 12 | Garfield |
HONORABLE MENTION
| Name | Grade | School |
| Savannah Best | 12 | New Milford |
| Julia Couch | 12 | Cresskill |
| Ava Eisenman | 11 | Garfield |
| Jasmin Vazquez | 10 | Paterson Charter |
| Katherine Nardone | 12 | Secaucus |
| Breaghan Toal | 12 | Harrison |
| Anniah Ashmeade | 12 | Manchester Regional |
| Valerie Ramirez | 12 | Palisades Park |
