First Team Group 1
- P: Connor Friedel, Hasbrouck Heights, Sr
Second Team Group 2
- 2B: Gabriel Francisco, Rutherford, Sr.
- DH: Dom Ciani, Rutherford, Sr.
Third Team Group 2
- U: John Hacker, Saddle Brook, Sr.
Second Team Group 1
- C: Nick Cuccio, Hasbrouck Heights, Sr.
- 1B: Ryan Scannelli, Pompton Lakes, Sr.
- 3B: Nick Rizos, Wood-Ridge, Jr.
- DH: Brendan Hughes, Park Ridge, Sr.
Third Team Group 1
- P: Trey Packen, Wood-Ridge, Jr.
- C: Mike Sarlo, Wood-Ridge, Jr.
- OF: Rocco DeMenna, Waldwick, Jr.
- DH: Tyler Sansone, Midland Park, Sr.