| 2025 Athletic Director of the Year | |
| American Division | |
| Tom Giuffre-Garfield | |
| Colonial Division | |
| Art Mazzacca-Hawthorne | |
| Liberty Division | |
| Dino Eliopoulos / Pal Pk | |
| Meadowlands Division | |
| Charlie Vellis / Wallington | |
| National Division | |
| Sean Dolaghan / Harrison | |
| Patriot Division | |
| Pat Clark / Midland Park | |
